The Tyranny of Merit Titelbild

The Tyranny of Merit

What’s Become of the Common Good?

 Reinhören
Dieses Angebot sichern 0,00 € - kostenlos hören
Angebot endet am 16.12.2025 um 23:59 Uhr. Es gelten die Audible Nutzungsbedingungen.
Bist du Amazon Prime-Mitglied?
Audible 60 Tage kostenlos testen
Für die ersten drei Monate erhältst du die Audible-Mitgliedschaft für nur 0,99 € pro Monat.
Pro Monat bekommst du ein Guthaben für einen beliebigen Titel aus unserem gesamten Premium-Angebot. Dieser bleibt für immer in deiner Bibliothek.
Höre tausende enthaltene Hörbücher, Audible-Originale, Podcasts und vieles mehr.
Pausiere oder kündige dein Abo monatlich.
Aktiviere das kostenlose Probeabo mit der Option, monatlich flexibel zu pausieren oder zu kündigen.
Nach dem Probemonat bekommst du eine vielfältige Auswahl an Hörbüchern, Kinderhörspielen und Original Podcasts für 9,95 € pro Monat.
Wähle monatlich einen Titel aus dem Gesamtkatalog und behalte ihn.

The Tyranny of Merit

Von: Michael J. Sandel
Gesprochen von: Michael J Sandel
Dieses Angebot sichern 0,00 € - kostenlos hören

9,95 €/Monat nach 3 Monaten. Angebot endet am 16.12.2025 um 23:59 Uhr. Monatlich kündbar.

9,95 € pro Monat nach 30 Tagen. Monatlich kündbar.

Für 28,95 € kaufen

Für 28,95 € kaufen

ZEITLICH BEGRENZTES ANGEBOT. Nur 0,99 € pro Monat für die ersten 3 Monate. 3 Monate für 0,99 €/Monat, danach 9,95 €/Monat. Bedingungen gelten. Jetzt starten.

Über diesen Titel

Brought to you by Penguin.

These are dangerous times for democracy. We live in an age of winners and losers, where the odds are stacked in favour of the already fortunate. Stalled social mobility and entrenched inequality give the lie to the promise that 'you can make it if you try'. And the consequence is a brew of anger and frustration that has fuelled populist protest, with the triumph of Brexit and election of Donald Trump.

Michael J. Sandel argues that to overcome the polarised politics of our time, we must rethink the attitudes toward success and failure that have accompanied globalisation and rising inequality. Sandel highlights the hubris a meritocracy generates among the winners and the harsh judgement it imposes on those left behind. He offers an alternative way of thinking about success - more attentive to the role of luck in human affairs, more conducive to an ethic of humility and more hospitable to a politics of the common good.

©2020 Michael J. Sandel (P)2020 Penguin Audio Politik & Regierungen Soziale Klassen & wirtschaftliche Ungleichheit Soziologie

Diese Titel könnten dich auch interessieren

 Autocracy, Inc. Titelbild
Capital in the Twenty-First Century Titelbild
Abundance Titelbild
Careless People Titelbild
The Origins of Totalitarianism Titelbild
Why We're Polarized Titelbild
Kaput Titelbild
Unverdiente Ungleichheit Titelbild
Equality Titelbild
Eisiges Schweigen flussabwärts Titelbild
Hillbilly Elegy Titelbild
Empire of AI Titelbild
Misbehaving Titelbild
Tyranny of the Minority Titelbild
All Fours Titelbild
The Case Against Perfection Titelbild
Alle Sterne
Am relevantesten
The book touches upon a very important topic. However, it often feels repetitive and anecdotal. While important points are made throughout the book, these could’ve been presented in a much denser fashion.

Important topic, but could’ve been shorter

Ein Fehler ist aufgetreten. Bitte versuche es in ein paar Minuten noch einmal.
Ein sehr wichtiges Buch, wie ich finde. Sollte besonders für alle in politischen Funktionen Pflichtlektüre sein. Sehr angenehm zu hören und perfekt für unterwegs, da der Autor seine Argumente oft wiederholt.

Sehr empfehlenswert

Ein Fehler ist aufgetreten. Bitte versuche es in ein paar Minuten noch einmal.
Von einem liberalen Standpunkt aus sich einen Reim auf die Verwerfungen der Gegenwart innerhalb westlicher Gesellschaften und insbesondere der der USA zu machen, ist eine Herausforderung. Der Autor bietet neben einer Fülle von Beispielen aus dem politisch-sozialen Tagesgeschäft eine durchaus schlüssige Gesamtargumentation an, die allerdings vergleichsweise konventionell, man könnte sagen: klassisch aufklärerisch und getragen von amerikanischen Denktraditionen daherkommt. Wir erhalten so eine fundierte, allerdings wenig überraschende theoretische Grundlage zum Verständnis gegenwärtiger gesellschaftlicher Konflikte.

Fundierte liberale Sichtweise auf politische Herausforderungen der Gegewart

Ein Fehler ist aufgetreten. Bitte versuche es in ein paar Minuten noch einmal.
Sandel lays out the misconceptions around meritocracy in a very comprehensive and easily understandable way, and - importantly - also offers solutions. However, the book is very repetitive, giving the same anecdotes multiple times and explaining everything at length without going into depth. It's also centred around US politics, which isn't a negative as such but I wasn't aware of this and personally have no special interest in the US. I'd recommend Sandel's TED talk before recommending this book.

Slow but insightful

Ein Fehler ist aufgetreten. Bitte versuche es in ein paar Minuten noch einmal.
Well, of course the content can be compressed and the one philosphical chapter could be skipped. For hurry readers this is appearently an issue. But for me it is perfectly fine. So I got a deeper understanding of the author's ethic and moral ideas.
And his explanation of today's class struggle is very plausible, not only in US but also across Europe.

Very reasonable

Ein Fehler ist aufgetreten. Bitte versuche es in ein paar Minuten noch einmal.
I would recommend this book to all students, especially in business / managerial fields. It proposes refreshing views on our society and politics.

Fascinating read

Ein Fehler ist aufgetreten. Bitte versuche es in ein paar Minuten noch einmal.
This is a complete seminar, a crash course from a Harvard teacher, and a wonderful audiobook.
Much has been said about the current upsurge of extremist political thought around the world and these books approach the subject in a refreshing way, not labeling militants or retreaters, but tying them all together in the causes of inequality and offering alternatives to heal our broken society.
A masterpiece that will help you to reassess much of the value system in which our society is placed.

Marvelous, and insigtfull work...

Ein Fehler ist aufgetreten. Bitte versuche es in ein paar Minuten noch einmal.
I'm trying to wrap my head around what there might be to say for and against meritocracy. I had just finished "The Meritocracy Trap" by Daniel Markovits, which was, more or less, a condemnation of American Meritocracy. I probably shouldn't have listened to this audiobook right afterwards, because I tend to confound them in my head and have some difficulty teasing them apart.
But, Michael J. Sandel is less vitriol in his attack on the American meritocracy than Markovits. Yet, he does call it a tyranny, which is a pretty strong wording. I believe his main quarrel with 'merit' and the meritocracy, is that it is 'unjust'.
I believe he's a moral philosopher, as he has some enlightening and interesting discussions of both Hayek (economist) and John Rawls.
I believe he takes issue with Hayeks economic liberalism, because in the end it is unjust and has too little respect or too little concern for the common good. Hayek is too concerned about individual freedom, and I think he criticizes him for focusing too narrowly on market and monetary value as the real value of things, goods and people. It's the old saying about the price system and the economy, which know the price of everything, but the value of nothing. What does have value to Sandler is people's dignity, self-esteem, having a productive life. Even John Rawls' ideas about fairness and justice does he seem to have issues with. The idea that we can accept some kind of meritocracy as long as it benefits (all) other people more, when some people have more, get more, make more, is not one that Sandler finds, is right or just.
He insists on the 'fact' that people without a college degree is frowned upon, people look down at them, and those who have gotten a college degree find themselves to be worthy, deserving of their privileges, while they have worked hard to get them. According to Sandel, a strong argument against meritocracy is that it breeds resentment between the 'deplorables' (Hilary Clinton's acrid term) and the meritorious. Yet, I would like to raise an objection. What society can Sandel point to, where there is no resentment between some groups or individuals? Has there ever been, and can there ever be? I'm somewhat skeptical on that point, yet it seems to be an important issue to Sandel - the striving for a society where everyone gets social recognition for their work, existence and effort. In many ways it's a laudable and humanistic goal, yet I'd like to ask whether he believes we can achieve something were everyone feels recognized to the full extent, which they fell entitled to. To paraphrase the bonmot about democracy, I still can't get rid of the suspicion that meritocracy is the worst and most unjust kind of societal order, except for all the others.
I'm not a US citizen, but a Danish citizen, and as two meritocratic societies (Denmark and USA), there are differences. Education is free and a lot of effort is put into qualifying people for all kind of jobs in Denmark. And yet, resentment against other professions and chauvinism about one's own are rampant or ubiquitous. Everybody seems to find their attribution to be undervalued and others overvalued.
Sandel also address the question of whether the meritocracy creates more wealth and prosperity. I believe that he does acknowledge that a free, meritocratic market economy, historically, has created more prosperity. Yet, it doesn't seem, in the end, to weigh in significantly, because it makes too many people superfluous. People don't just have a right and interest in becoming more prosperous, they also want to contribute and live meaningful lives. The American middle class appears to have become only marginally more prosperous, but have lost out on living a meaningful life and contributing to the common good.
He might be right, but I also suspect that his perspective is somehow parochial, because the global economy has been a boon and a good fortune to billions of poor people in the world. Yet the moral drama played out in this book is a drama between a college-educated America and non-college-educated America. I suspect this as being a to narrow perspective. I would also have liked if he had taken issue with Robert Nozick's argument about that the distribution of goods are just, as long as it has happened through voluntary transactions. I can also find it mind-bugling and incredible, how some bankers, CEO's, investors get formidable remunerations, yet at the same time, if that is what it is worth to some very wealthy firms, individuals, investors, then who am I to say that it's wrong. I don't have a very good response to this argument. Especially not, if it's combined with an argument and data about how the system somehow does work for some common good like greater prosperity.

Sandel has written an interesting book about merit(ocracy). I can't exactly recognize everything he writes about, and I suspect that part of the animosity and discontent with 'merit' stems from a unique American perspective and version of capitalism and meritocracy, which give to little room for, well, living.
(Finally, I made a personal note about a section, where he tells about the argument about being "on the right side of history", which according to Sandell became a frequent figure of speech from Bill Clinton and forwards. I can use this in my classes about argumentation.)

Toughtfull and thorough argument about meritocracy

Ein Fehler ist aufgetreten. Bitte versuche es in ein paar Minuten noch einmal.
Sandel at his best. Thorough, balanced, and decidedly focused on good outcomes for all of society.

Merit is not the answer

Ein Fehler ist aufgetreten. Bitte versuche es in ein paar Minuten noch einmal.
The basic thesis is interesting and good argued for but the book repeats itself over and over, should have been a blog post

This book should have been a blog post

Ein Fehler ist aufgetreten. Bitte versuche es in ein paar Minuten noch einmal.
Mehr Rezensionen ansehen