I don't like Snow - I like Snow - Do I like Snow?

A whirlwind of emotions. I really liked this book, especially bc it gave me an insight into the adolescent mind of one of my most hated characters from the earlier (or later) mockingbird books.
I really appreciated the fact, that it wasn't just a carbon copy of the earlier books (I dare say, that Book 2 and 3 were very similar to book 1) but it gives a new angle and many more insights.

The most shocking part for me was, that my feelings toward young Snow kept changing, Suzanne Collins did very well on that account.

For me a must-listen if you liked the mockingjay-books.

I didn't mind the speaker, not amazing but I didn't hear any Mickey-Mouse-female voices other comments mentioned.

Sie haben diese Rezension bewertet.

Wir haben Ihre Meldung erhalten und werden die Rezension prüfen.

Not the narrator's fault,

but there were a lot of songs in this one, and having them read flat out was not much fun at times...
Aside from that it was very well narrated.

It's a great story that had me hooked early on gripped me to the end. The slow corruption of a young man was very well done and believable.

Sie haben diese Rezension bewertet.

Wir haben Ihre Meldung erhalten und werden die Rezension prüfen.

Great story, terrible reader

I don’t know what it is about the narrator that really irritates me. He sounds awfully monotone and the way he narrates the songs which make up a major part of the book just completely ruined it for me. I had a hard time focusing on the content because of this and I think I’ll buy the book and read it for myself instead because there’s a lot of details I missed.

Sie haben diese Rezension bewertet.

Wir haben Ihre Meldung erhalten und werden die Rezension prüfen.

Okay but not mindblowing

The story is interesting and kept me listening. Personally I found it to have some weaknesses, particularly the behaviour of the main character in the final chapters of the book. While everything appears to have been there right from the start to me the events that unfolded seemed still a bit far fetched, which tells me that the character development lacks believability. Overall, I found myself entertained by the (maybe slightly too long) story and that's a good thing. I'd give it 3.5 stars, but since I have to choose between three or four, I'd rather go with the three. good fun!

I have serious problems with the reader though. While his tone and intonation fits the main character well, in my opinion, his intonation of women is terrible. Furthermore, for a story where songs have such an important part in, the spoken word recitation of the respective lyrics is horrible as well, lacking rhythm and gravitas. This is especially true for the hanging tree song, since there's an actual version performed in the hunger games movies.

If you're looking for smth more to read/listen in the Hunger Games universe, this prequel is interesting enough to check out. be aware that, at least to me, it comes with some flaws.

Sie haben diese Rezension bewertet.

Wir haben Ihre Meldung erhalten und werden die Rezension prüfen.

2 Leute fanden das hilfreich

Interessante Geschichte, kommt aber nicht an die Trilogie heran.

Inhaltlich fand ich es super spannend mehr über Snow zu erfahren, ich empfand den Fortschritt der Geschichte am Anfang als sehr lang, während ich am Ende für mich zu viel Tempo aufgenommen wurde um die Charakterentscheidungen vollends zu verstehen. Den Sprecher fand ich gut, allerdings fand ich es schwierig die Rollen auseinander zu halten. Da habe ich bei anderen Sprechern bereits ein besseres Repertoire gehört. Ich bin gespannt auf den Film, denn ich denke ohne klaren Einblick in die Gedanken wird es schwer fallen die Motive und Handlungen nachvollziehen zu können. Aber so ging es mir schon bei den Hunger Games.

Sie haben diese Rezension bewertet.

Wir haben Ihre Meldung erhalten und werden die Rezension prüfen.

1 Person fand das hilfreich

Average

I thought it was quite sad that the narator read out all the nice songs instead of singing them - especially the ones which have a well known tune.
Also, the story didn't really capture me as much as the original hunger games did. Took me ages to finish it.

Sie haben diese Rezension bewertet.

Wir haben Ihre Meldung erhalten und werden die Rezension prüfen.

1 Person fand das hilfreich

Cruel

I think it was a good book, but cruel like the rest of them! It gets you to think. By listening to it you get into Snows mind, which is frightening.

Sie haben diese Rezension bewertet.

Wir haben Ihre Meldung erhalten und werden die Rezension prüfen.

Definetly worth a read but not as good as the previous books

I think the most interesting thing about the whole story was seeing a different side of the universe we didn't get to see before. Like the peacekeepers training or the Capitol. I don't know what to make of the ending or the relationship between Snow and Lucy Grey. The ending was kind of aprubt and the "fallout" between them a switch up. Kinda feels like we are left with half a plot point hanging in the end. Overall not bad if u are a fan, definitely recommended but still just a 3/5 overall for me. The narrator did his best but wasn't the best choice for reading here either.

Sie haben diese Rezension bewertet.

Wir haben Ihre Meldung erhalten und werden die Rezension prüfen.

sehr spannend

spannend und super geschrieben
das Ende war etwas rushed aber ich bin echt beeindruckt
freu mich schon auf die Verfilmung

Sie haben diese Rezension bewertet.

Wir haben Ihre Meldung erhalten und werden die Rezension prüfen.

A masterpiece.

I've been following Mrs. Collins' writing for quite some time now. Back in the 2000's, when I was still a child myself, I read her Underland Chronicles and enjoyed every minute of it. It was the way she constantly introduced new, more fantastical concepts that made me stay on edge during reading that series.

(Attention, the following section includes spoilers about the Hunger Games trilogy, but I assume most people who are interested in this book have already read it)

The Hunger Games trilogy, however, disappointed me a bit. I did not like the main character, Katniss Everdeen, one bit. She was a stereotypical hero. No bad side to her, just pure goodness. A Mary Sue, if you will. All "flaws" she had were just disguised positive traits (lacking obidience to authority, for example).
Same applies to pretty much all "good" characters throughout the series. The twist in the final book trying to spin Gale Hawthorne and president Coin as grey characters is nothing but a faint hearted attempt at ambivalence.
Furthermore, the whole universe of Panem seemed inorganic. The capitol system was far too little fleshed out to actually be believable. Oh, and it had an incredibly obnoxious fan base that would discard any criticism of the book as a personal attack on the writer. Please don't get me wrong - these were still solid books I liked to read, but they very far from perfect and worse than the Underland Chronicles.

This book fixes all of this. It gives a deep look into the history and customs of Panem and how the capitol became like it is. The version of Panem presented here, 65 years before the events of the trilogy, is far more believable and akin to our world. With this missing link, the further development into the bizarre world that is presented to Katniss and friends seems more likely.

The main reason why this book is so good, however, are the characters. Coriolanus Snow is so much better than Katniss Everdeen, damn, I can not emphasize this enough. He's such a well written gray (how ironic) character. At all times you could sympathize with his actions and behaviour (he actually has a very, very uncanny resemblance to real life me. I think there was only one situation in the whole book where I wouldn't have made the exact same decision he made, which makes me feel kind of uneasy), still he doesn't get out of character and it is absolutely believable that this bright young man will one day become the brutal dictator Snow we all loathe. There's also a lot of irony to be found in his young life compared to what happens 65 years later, but I won't spoil that.

Lucy Gray Beard, the second main character and the tribute from District 12, is a perfect match for Coriolanus. Bright, flashy and cute, someone who plays with her charisma to get what she wants. She's not an angel, either, which makes her even more interesting. Though it is never clear, she sometimes seems manipulative, even brutal. Those are her two sides - songbird and snake. Quite different from Katniss, but similar in some good ways.
These two people naturally fair very well together, which makes the love story that unfolds very natural and unforced. The dynamic between them is spectacular, but that's something Collins has always been exceptionally good at.

The supporting characters are very believable as well. Doctor Gaul is a believable sociopath, something you rarely find in novels nowadays. Sejanus Plinth is getting on your nerves, but that's intentional. He's the "too good for this world" kind of person you'd find in real life as well. He and his father actually remind me a lot of Thomas and Hanno Buddenbrook, they have a very similar character dynamic. Dean Highbottom is a very believable version of the Oppenheimer typus ("I have become death, the destroyer of worlds!"). If I had to nitpick, I didn't like the lack of attention the rest of the Covey (Lucy Gray's family and Co-Musicians) received. They stayed in the background so much you often forgot they were even there. They were so irrelevant to the experience, I can't remember any of their names right now except for Maud Ivory, even though they were nearly always present during the second half of the book and I just finished it.

Philosophically speaking, this novel deals with the question of anarchism vs. statism, both in their most extreme forms (living under an oppressive totalitarian regime vs. living in the wilderness). It's a literary battle between the state philosophy of John Locke (represented by Lucy Gray) and Thomas Hobbes (represented by Coriolanus). I found it kind of blunt to begin the novel with quotes directly taken from their works. The dialogues between Dr. Gaul and Coriolanus were also a bit too much "in your face". People who know a bit about philosophy would've understood anyways and it might distract the casual reader. Nonetheless, this theme is very elegantly woven into the story and the symbolism is really well made.

One thing I also wanted to mention as well is the ending. I obviously can't spoil it for all of you, so it must suffice that it was one of the most brilliant endings of a story I've ever read. It had a very deep meaning that resonated with me. I'm sure most of you will like it as well.

All of this made the novel seem... adult. I can't describe it, really, but it kind of feels as if the writing of Suzanne Collins has finally fully grown up. This is a literary piece of world class. It's not children's literature anymore, not in the slightest.

It is thus far the best book I have read this year, which is very impressive considering that I read "Romance of the Three Empires" by Luo Guanzhong a few weeks ago.

I don't know wether people who were very into Katniss will like this book much. It might even be a disappointment. But for me, it's Suzanne Collins' magnum opus.

Sie haben diese Rezension bewertet.

Wir haben Ihre Meldung erhalten und werden die Rezension prüfen.